The Hyperion Cantos: A Retrospective

In my most recent reread of the Hyperion Cantos, I paid closer attention to the author’s prose and technique.  I already knew the story, the characters, and the twists, but given how multilayered the prose is, with subtle twists that are further obfuscated by the author hitting the reader over the head with very obvious turns in the narrative, I set on appreciating the subtleties of the writing style.

As I mentioned in my review of one of the books, the writing feels almost cynical in its clinical, polished form.  Simmons ruthlessly plays with the readers’ emotions, bludgeoning them with very elaborate human tragedies.  The readers get emotionally invested in the protagonists, and they keep on reading even when the books devolve into a relatively standard space opera fare.  Upon closer examination, however, the books’ subtleties color the stories and make each sequel feel as fresh as its predecessor.

The tetralogy has popularized a structure that many works tried to follow, with varying degrees of success.  The one that did the best job was Ada Palmer’s Terra Ignota, which is sometimes compared to the Hyperion Cantos for this reason.  The basic premise was to tell separate stories in each book, each in a different format, but with the same characters.  This would keep the books fresh, and the readers won’t get bored with more of the same.  To keep the readers coming back, the hook must thus be different: emotional investment in the characters.

In his first book, Simmons needed to combine the required worldbuilding with developing fascinating protagonists that the readers would return to.  He did it superbly, by designing small personal stories for each of the characters.  On an intimate level, the tragedies may be momentous, but on the galactic scale of his universe, they are like specs of dust.  So, we learn about a world that was settled a long time ago, and a quaint university town.  We keep it in the back of our mind, while we are completely engrossed in the tragedy of a woman aging backwards.  We also learn about a tragic love story that consisted of several episodes where one half of the couple aged, while the other didn’t.  We are exposed to the evil of the Hegemony, as modern-day colonizers.  We also indulge into the story of a decadent artist, but at the same time we learn about instant teleportation and its effects on the rest of the universe.  Every time we follow a character, we gain a few pieces of the worldbuilding puzzle, which are slowly fitting together.

We then approach the second book with a very good idea of Simmons’ universe, and we are ready to subconsciously use the knowledge to seamlessly follow the end of the protagonists’ journey.  But wait!  The second book is about something else.  And just as Hyperion seemed to incidentally build a fascinating world, The Fall of Hyperion keeps the fate of the original protagonists as a side note, crowded out by much larger events that take full advantage of the worldbuilding, which so insidiously lodged into our minds in the first book.

The sequel is indeed different.  This is most obvious in the narration style, where Simmons devises an ingenious mix of personal account and god’s eye view.  More importantly, however, is that he can finally play with his world, perhaps in a way he originally intended.  Instead of personal stories, he develops a grand strategy between two opposing forces that may or may not know that their opponent is even aware of them.  While he still does some worldbuilding, there’s nothing new there, just building on what he described in the first book.  So how to keep the fans of Hyperion interested?  By still following the original protagonists in whom the readers have become so invested.  The chapters alternate with real world events, as if to force the readers to follow the new storyline.  The original pilgrims could have been disposed of in the first act, and have two acts of galactic-level politics and warfare, but many readers would have tuned out.  But Simmons knows what’s best for you, and he’ll force-feed you the new storyline, whether you want or not.  Then, towards the very end, when the stories of the original pilgrims have largely concluded, you realize that you are actually interested in the outcome of the war between the Hegemony and Technocore, and suddenly you are thankful that Simmons forced this narrative into your brain.

Then came Endymion, and Simmons changed gears again.  He may have thought that the readers would not fall for the same trick twice, or maybe he had ideas for a grand story that was different from the original.  So, this book has only very tenuous connections with the previous duology, in the form of some characters (or their memory), and the repetition of a few themes from the original.  The book begins with a fresh critique of colonization, which is very reminiscent of the Consul’s story from the first book in the series.  This, more than anything else, evokes a sense of familiarity with the Hyperion universe.  It allows the author to gently ease us into the new narrator, who has nothing in common with the original protagonists.

Endymion takes place nearly three centuries after the original story, so even though the physical aspects of the universe are the same as before, the social, political and technological aspects need rebuilding again.  Finding some similarities helps the readers to regain their balance and dive straight into the new adventure.

An adventure it is.  The narrative structure changes again.  While Hyperion was a series of first-person novelettes set in the same universe, and its sequel was a space opera through the eyes of a bystander who had unparalleled view of the story, Endymion is a road adventure.  Raul, the narrator, is essentially describing a road trip of a group of outlaws, pursued by police.  The outlaws may be the good guys and the police may be corrupt, as is usually the case in this kind of a story, but it’s a structure that has been played out many times before.  In fact, I even found parallels between this book and the movie The Fugitive, where Tommy Lee Jones’ character has a wonderful redemption arc, from a dogged police pursuer to someone sympathetic and ultimately helping the fugitive’s case.  Farther-Captain Frederico de Soya may have been modeled after this character.

I find Endymion to be the weakest of the series.  Not because it is so drastically different from the original duology that I grew to love, but because it does not stand on its own.  Simmons uses it for a build-up for his last book.  He once again sets the universe in a way that would make the greatest impact in the last book in the series, but due to the elaborate plot he prepares for, he is forced to take many shortcuts.  One of the most egregious ones is that he never fully develops Raul into a protagonist.  Simmons wants another near-omniscient narrator, but he struggles with justifying his existence.  Raul adds very little to the merry band of outlaws, save for a few foolish attempts at heroism, which usually only cause trouble.

The last book, The Rise of Endymion, is the culmination of the buildup Simmons did in the previous book.  He goes absolutely wild with the set pieces, and political and religious philosophy.  Simmons knows he is done with the series, and he pulls out all the stops.  To his credit, he still strives to close all loose ends, and he succeeds better than most other authors that I know of.  In terms of genres, this is a book of religious philosophy with a space opera backdrop, and as such it pleases comparably fewer readers.  Those who like space operas are annoyed with the philosophical interruptions, and those who like to talk about religion may get angry with his various blasphemies.  Simmons doesn’t seem to care anymore.  His editorial control is slipping, and his once very tight and controlled prose is all over the place.  I get the feeling that this is his message he wanted to say from the very beginning, and now he is opening the floodgates of his thoughts.  For me, this worked very well, and despite the book’s length, it felt like a wild and quite short ride.

I have never been exposed to Dan Simmons in any other way than his books.  I never heard him speak, nor do I follow him on social media, and I even didn’t come across any articles about him.  So, I may be completely wrong about any of my assumptions I laid out in my retrospective of his most famous opus.  However, I like to think that I experienced the mind of an author, and its evolution of thought.  What started as a very deliberate, polished prose, has slowly built up into an explosive expression of his thoughts.  He did it twice, with the second books of his two duologies.  He could control this explosion in The Fall of Hyperion, perhaps because he planned to write more within this universe.  He showed absolutely no self-control in The Rise of Endymion, though, and I think the books and the series are far better for it.  Some people say, with regret, that we were born too late to explore the Earth, and too soon to explore the stars.  I say I’m glad I was born just in time to explore books like the Hyperion Cantos.

This entry was posted in Book reviews, Opinions and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.